05 Will AI Make Us Lazy or Sharper Thinkers?

Not long ago, someone on my team told me:

👉 “I haven’t tried AI because I don’t want to lose my critical thinking skills.”

I get it. The concern feels valid. But here’s the truth: using AI doesn’t replace critical thinking—it requires it.

You don’t get valuable results from AI by passively typing random prompts. You get them by asking sharp questions, framing problems clearly, and evaluating the answers with judgment. That’s critical thinking in action.

And funny enough, that’s a muscle I trained a long time ago—as a military interrogator. Back then, it wasn’t about asking more questions, it was about asking the right ones. No harsh lights or good cop/bad cop here—but the principle is the same. AI rewards clarity and curiosity.

🛠 Lazy vs. Learners

Here’s the reality: there will always be lazy people. AI won’t change that. Lazy is gonna do lazy—with or without new technology.

But learners? Learners will use AI as a force multiplier. They’ll treat it like a telescope—something that expands their perspective, not shrinks it. They’ll see further, move faster, and get sharper insights because they’re willing to engage with the tool, not avoid it.

The gap between lazy and learners is already widening.

🔄 We’ve Seen This Movie Before

This isn’t the first time we’ve panicked about technology “making us dumber.”

  • Calculators → People swore kids would never learn math again. Instead, calculators freed us up for higher-level problem solving.

  • Spellcheck & grammar tools → Critics said no one would learn how to write. Instead, strong writers just got faster at editing.

  • Wikipedia → Remember when everyone warned it was unreliable and would ruin research? It became one of the most valuable open knowledge projects ever.

  • Google → “Search engines will dumb us down.” The fear was that no one would learn how to do “real” research if Google just gave you the answer. Reality? Google didn’t kill curiosity—it amplified it. People research more, not less. The depth varies, sure, but the baseline of access went up.

AI is simply the next chapter in this long story.

🕵️‍♀️ The “Cheating” Myth

Yes, some people will “cheat” with AI. But people said the same about calculators, spellcheck, and Google.

The reality: tools don’t erase ability—they reveal it. If you don’t understand the problem, AI will just help you make mistakes faster. If you do understand it, AI becomes jet fuel.

💡 Clear Take

AI isn’t going to make us all lazy. It’s going to make the divide between lazy and learners even sharper.

Lazy will stay lazy. Learners will use AI to think deeper, move faster, and grow sharper.
And the real differentiator? The people who know how to ask the right questions.

Racheal Vicari

Hi, I’m Racheal Vicari.

I lead business transformation at the intersection of AI, strategy, and delivery—focused on helping enterprise clients solve real-world problems with real results.

As a Director in Technology Engineering at KPMG, I work primarily with Fortune 100 clients in the Life Sciences industry. I specialize in turning complexity into clarity, and building AI-enabled solutions that are both scalable and practical.

Before consulting, I served in operational intelligence as a Russian linguist and interrogator—an experience that taught me how to think critically, ask the right questions, and deliver under pressure. That mindset still drives my leadership style today: calm, focused, and relentlessly outcomes-driven.

I'm passionate about advancing women in tech, mentoring future leaders, and designing systems that actually work in the real world—not just in slides.

https://rachealvicari.com
Previous
Previous

06 Do you Need a Lab Coat to Lead AI

Next
Next

04 Why Big Tech Is Paying a Few AI Geniuses Crazy Money